Screening Saham

## Mengapa Screening Sistematis Adalah Game Changer?
### Masalah Tanpa Sistem:
```
Investor A (No System):
├─ Baca berita: "GOTO bakal profit tahun ini!"
├─ Lihat influencer: "BBRI undervalued!"
├─ Teman kasih tips: "BREN mau listing, pasti naik!"
└─ Hasil: Portfolio berantakan, no conviction, panic sell saat turun
```
### Dengan Sistem Screening:
```
Investor B (Systematic):
├─ Top down: Sektor finansial attractive (early easing cycle)
├─ Screen 40+ bank stocks dengan kriteria ketat
├─ Dapat 5 kandidat terbaik
├─ Deep dive fundamental + teknikal + bandarmologi
├─ Pilih 2-3 dengan conviction tertinggi
└─ Entry dengan sizing & SL jelas
└─ Hasil: High conviction, tahan drawdown, profit konsisten
```
---
## 1. Framework Screening 5 Tahap (The Funnel System)
```
STAGE 1: Universe Definition (800+ stocks)
↓ Filter makro & sektor
STAGE 2: Quantitative Screening (200 stocks)
↓ Filter metrik fundamental
STAGE 3: Quality Check (50 stocks)
↓ Deep dive laporan keuangan
STAGE 4: Bandarmologi Check (20 stocks)
↓ Analisis transaksi broker & asing
STAGE 5: Technical Timing (10 stocks)
↓ Entry point & risk-reward
FINAL: 3-5 Conviction Buys
```
---
## 2. STAGE 1: Universe Definition
### A. Pre-Filter Berdasarkan Top Down (Dari Sesi 3)
**Contoh Aplikasi:**
```
Hasil Top Down Analysis (Januari 2024):
├─ Cycle: Late cycle → Early easing
├─ Sektor pilihan: Financials, Consumer Staples, Plantation
└─ Market: 40% IDN, 50% US, 10% Cash
ACTION:
Fokus screening hanya di 3 sektor tersebut
└─ Jangan buang waktu screen saham tech saat cycle tidak mendukung
```
### B. Liquidity Filter (Hanya Saham Likuid)
**Kriteria Minimum:**
| **Market** | **Metric** | **Minimum** | **Rationale** |
|-----------|-----------|------------|--------------|
| **IDN** | Market Cap | > Rp 5 triliun | Likuiditas & institutional interest |
| **IDN** | Avg Daily Value | > Rp 10 miliar | Easy entry/exit |
| **IDN** | Free Float | > 20% | Cukup float untuk retail |
| **US** | Market Cap | > $1 billion | Mid-cap ke atas |
| **US** | Avg Daily Volume | > 500k shares | Likuiditas |
**Tools:**
- **IDN:** Stockbit screener, RTI Business
- **US:** Finviz.com, TradingView screener
**Action:**
```
Masuk Stockbit/RTI → Screener
├─ Set: Market cap > 5T
├─ Set: Avg value > 10M
└─ Filter sektor: Financials, Consumer, Plantation
Result: ~200 stocks → 60-80 stocks
```
---
## 3. STAGE 2: Quantitative Screening (The Numbers Don't Lie)
### A. Fundamental Metrics - IDN Stocks
#### **Kategori 1: Profitabilitas**
| **Metric** | **Formula** | **Minimum** | **Excellent** | **Dimana Lihat** |
|-----------|-----------|------------|--------------|----------------|
| **ROE** | Net Income / Equity | > 10% | > 20% | Laporan keuangan, Stockbit |
| **ROA** | Net Income / Total Assets | > 5% | > 10% | Laporan keuangan |
| **Net Profit Margin** | Net Income / Revenue | > 5% | > 15% | Laporan keuangan |
| **ROIC** | NOPAT / Invested Capital | > 10% | > 15% | Hitung manual |
**Interpretation:**
```
ROE > 15% + ROA > 8% = Bisnis yang sangat profitable
ROE tinggi tapi ROA rendah = Leverage tinggi (hati-hati)
Net Margin > 15% = Pricing power kuat (competitive advantage)
```
**Stockbit Screener Setup:**
```
Filter:
├─ ROE > 15%
├─ Net Margin > 10%
└─ Market Cap > 5T
Result: 60-80 stocks → 30-40 stocks
```
---
#### **Kategori 2: Valuasi (Apakah Harganya Masuk Akal?)**
| **Metric** | **Formula** | **Ideal Range** | **Notes** |
|-----------|-----------|----------------|-----------|
| **PER** | Price / EPS | 10-20x | Sesuaikan dengan sektor & growth |
| **PBV** | Price / Book Value per Share | 1-3x | < 1x bisa value trap atau distress |
| **PEG** | PER / Earnings Growth Rate | < 1 | Undervalued relative to growth |
| **EV/EBITDA** | Enterprise Value / EBITDA | 8-12x | Lebih akurat dari PER (include debt) |
| **Dividend Yield** | Dividend per Share / Price | > 3% | Untuk income investor |
**Sector-Specific PER Benchmark (IDN):**
| **Sektor** | **Normal PER** | **Expensive** | **Cheap** |
|-----------|---------------|--------------|----------|
| **Banking** | 12-18x | > 20x | < 10x |
| **Consumer Staples** | 20-30x | > 35x | < 18x |
| **Plantation** | 10-15x | > 18x | < 8x |
| **Mining/Coal** | 5-10x | > 12x | < 5x (cyclical bottom) |
| **Technology** | 25-40x | > 50x | < 20x |
| **Property** | 8-15x | > 18x | < 6x |
**Cara Pakai:**
```
Contoh: BBCA
├─ PER saat ini: 18x
├─ PER historis 5 tahun: 15-22x
├─ Sector avg: 15x
└─ Conclusion: Slightly expensive vs sector, tapi dalam range historis
└─ Jika top down support → masih bisa masuk (premium deserved)
```
**Advanced: PEG Ratio (Peter Lynch Favorite)**
```
BBCA:
├─ PER: 18x
├─ Earnings Growth (5Y avg): 12%
└─ PEG = 18 / 12 = 1.5
Interpretation:
├─ PEG < 1 = Undervalued (relative to growth)
├─ PEG 1-2 = Fair value
└─ PEG > 2 = Overvalued
Action: BBCA fair value, not a screaming buy on valuation alone
```
---
#### **Kategori 3: Financial Health (Kesehatan Keuangan)**
| **Metric** | **Formula** | **Safe Zone** | **Red Flag** |
|-----------|-----------|------------|-------------|
| **DER** | Total Debt / Equity | < 1x (non-financial) | > 2x |
| **Current Ratio** | Current Assets / Current Liabilities | > 1.5x | < 1x |
| **Interest Coverage** | EBIT / Interest Expense | > 5x | < 2x |
| **Free Cash Flow** | Operating CF - Capex | Positive & growing | Negative consistently |
**Sector Exception:**
```
Banking: DER tinggi adalah normal (leverage bisnis model)
├─ Focus on: CAR (Capital Adequacy Ratio) > 14%
├─ NPL (Non-Performing Loan) < 3%
└─ LDR (Loan to Deposit Ratio) 80-92% (optimal)
```
**Red Flags yang HARUS Dihindari:**
```
❌ DER > 2x (kecuali banking/financial)
❌ Current Ratio < 1 (liquidity crisis risk)
❌ Interest Coverage < 2x (struggle bayar bunga)
❌ Negative FCF 3 tahun berturut-turut (burning cash)
❌ Revenue turun 2 tahun berturut-turut (declining business)
```
---
#### **Kategori 4: Growth (Momentum Bisnis)**
| **Metric** | **Period** | **Minimum** | **Excellent** |
|-----------|-----------|------------|--------------|
| **Revenue Growth** | YoY | > 5% | > 15% |
| **Earnings Growth** | YoY | > 10% | > 20% |
| **EPS Growth** | 3Y CAGR | > 10% | > 15% |
| **Book Value Growth** | 3Y CAGR | > 8% | > 12% |
**Cara Hitung (Manual di Excel):**
```
Revenue Growth YoY:
(Revenue 2023 - Revenue 2022) / Revenue 2022 × 100%
EPS CAGR 3 tahun:
((EPS 2023 / EPS 2020)^(1/3)) - 1
Example BBCA:
├─ EPS 2020: Rp 500
├─ EPS 2023: Rp 650
└─ CAGR = ((650/500)^(1/3)) - 1 = 9.1%
```
**Kombinasi Ideal:**
```
Growth + Value Sweet Spot:
├─ Earnings Growth > 15%
├─ PER < 15x
└─ PEG < 1
Result: High conviction buy
```
---
### B. Quantitative Screener - IDN (Template Lengkap)
**Conservative Growth Portfolio:**
```
Stockbit/RTI Screener:
├─ Market Cap > Rp 10T
├─ ROE > 15%
├─ DER < 1 (exclude financials)
├─ PER: 10-20x
├─ Revenue Growth (1Y) > 10%
├─ Free Float > 30%
└─ Avg Daily Value > Rp 20M
Expected result: 15-25 stocks
```
**Aggressive Growth Portfolio:**
```
├─ Market Cap > Rp 5T
├─ ROE > 20%
├─ Revenue Growth > 20%
├─ EPS Growth > 25%
├─ PER: accept up to 30x (if growth justify)
└─ Sector: Tech, Consumer Discretionary
Expected result: 10-15 stocks
```
**Dividend Income Portfolio:**
```
├─ Market Cap > Rp 10T
├─ Dividend Yield > 4%
├─ Payout Ratio: 40-70% (sustainable)
├─ ROE > 12%
├─ DER < 1
└─ Consecutive dividend payment > 5 years
Expected result: 10-20 stocks
```
---
### C. Quantitative Screening - US Stocks
**Tools:**
- **Finviz.com** (Free, powerful)
- **TradingView Stock Screener**
- **Yahoo Finance Screener**
#### **Finviz Screener Setup (Growth Stocks):**
```
Descriptive:
├─ Market Cap: +Large (>$10B) atau +Mid ($2-10B)
├─ Average Volume: >500K
Fundamental:
├─ P/E: Under 30
├─ PEG: Under 1.5
├─ ROE: Over 15%
├─ Debt/Eq: Under 0.5
├─ EPS growth this year: Over 15%
├─ EPS growth next year: Over 10%
├─ Sales growth past 5Y: Over 10%
Technical:
├─ Price: Above SMA50
├─ RSI: 40-70 (not overbought)
Result: Click "Elite" or export to CSV
```
**Sector-Specific (Example: Tech Growth):**
```
Finviz:
├─ Sector: Technology
├─ Market Cap: +Mid, +Large
├─ P/S (Price/Sales): Under 5
├─ EPS growth next 5Y: Over 15%
├─ Gross Margin: Over 50% (high margin tech)
├─ ROE: Over 20%
Result: 20-40 stocks
Then manually filter by moat & competitive advantage
```
---
## 4. STAGE 3: Quality Check (Deep Dive Fundamental)
Setelah quantitative filter, kita punya ~20-30 stocks.
**Sekarang deep dive 1-by-1.**
### A. Checklist Deep Dive per Saham (Alokasi 30-45 menit/saham)
#### **1. Business Model Understanding**
```
[ ] Apakah saya paham 100% bisnis ini?
├─ Produk/jasa apa yang dijual?
├─ Revenue stream dari mana?
├─ Customer base siapa?
└─ Siapa kompetitor utama?
[ ] Apakah bisnis ini simple atau kompleks?
└─ Warren Buffett: "Never invest in a business you cannot understand"
[ ] Apakah ada competitive advantage (moat)?
├─ Brand power (e.g., UNVR)
├─ Network effect (e.g., GOTO - debatable)
├─ Cost leadership (e.g., ACES logistics)
├─ Switching cost (e.g., BBCA - people jarang ganti bank)
└─ Regulatory moat (e.g., TLKM)
```
**Example: BBCA**
```
✅ Business model: Jelas (simpan-pinjam, fee-based income)
✅ Moat: Switching cost tinggi, brand trust, largest ATM network
✅ Revenue: Diversified (NII + fee income)
✅ Customer: Retail + SME + corporate (balanced)
✅ Risk: Regulasi BI, economic slowdown
```
---
#### **2. Management Quality**
```
[ ] Track record management?
└─ Cek LinkedIn CEO/CFO, tenure, previous achievement
[ ] Corporate governance score?
└─ ASEAN CG Scorecard, laporan CGPI
[ ] Insider ownership?
├─ > 10% ownership (skin in the game)
└─ Recent insider buying/selling? (cek di IDX announcements)
[ ] Red flags?
❌ Frequent related party transactions
❌ Frequent restatement laporan keuangan
❌ High turnover C-level executives
```
**Where to Check (IDN):**
- idx.co.id → Company → Corporate Actions
- Laporan Tahunan (Annual Report) - Section: Management Profile
- Google: "[Nama CEO] track record"
---
#### **3. Financial Deep Dive (Beyond Ratios)**
**Cek Laporan Keuangan 3 Tahun Terakhir:**
```
Revenue Analysis:
[ ] Tren naik konsisten? Atau fluktuatif?
[ ] Breakdown per segmen (jika ada)
└─ Segmen mana yang tumbuh? Yang declining?
[ ] Apakah growth organic atau dari akuisisi?
Margin Analysis:
[ ] Gross margin trend? (Naik = pricing power, Turun = kompetisi ketat)
[ ] Operating margin trend? (Efisiensi operasional)
[ ] Net margin trend? (Bottomline health)
Cash Flow Analysis:
[ ] Operating CF positif & growing?
[ ] FCF (Operating CF - Capex) positif?
[ ] Apakah FCF > Net Income? (Quality of earnings)
Balance Sheet:
[ ] Asset growth sesuai dengan revenue growth?
[ ] Inventory turnover (untuk retail/manufacture)? Makin cepat = makin bagus
[ ] Receivable days? Makin pendek = makin bagus (collect cash cepat)
```
**Red Flag Examples:**
```
❌ Revenue naik, tapi receivables naik lebih cepat
└─ Possible aggressive revenue recognition
❌ Net income tinggi, tapi Operating CF rendah/negatif
└─ Earnings quality rendah (paper profit)
❌ Debt naik signifikan tanpa diikuti asset produktif
└─ Debt untuk cover operational (bad sign)
```
---
#### **4. Industry & Competitive Position**
```
[ ] Posisi market share?
├─ #1, #2, #3 di industri?
└─ Trend naik atau turun?
[ ] Competitive landscape?
├─ Oligopoly (few players) = good
├─ Fragmented (many players) = race to bottom
└─ Monopoly = excellent tapi risky (regulasi)
[ ] Threat dari disruptor?
└─ Example: TAXI vs GOTO (disrupted)
└─ Example: Bank traditional vs Fintech (adapting)
[ ] Barrier to entry industri?
├─ Tinggi (capital intensive, regulasi) = protect incumbent
└─ Rendah = kompetisi intens
```
**Tools:**
- Google: "[Company name] market share Indonesia"
- Laporan Tahunan: Management Discussion & Analysis (MD&A)
- Industry reports (Frost & Sullivan, Gartner, dll - if accessible)
---
### B. Scoring System (Buat Objektif)
**Template Scoring (0-10 per kategori, total 100):**
| **Kategori** | **Weight** | **Score (0-10)** | **Weighted Score** |
|-------------|-----------|-----------------|-------------------|
| Business Model Clarity | 10% | | |
| Competitive Moat | 15% | | |
| Management Quality | 10% | | |
| Financial Health (DER, Current Ratio) | 15% | | |
| Profitability (ROE, Margin) | 20% | | |
| Growth (Revenue, EPS) | 15% | | |
| Valuation (PER, PBV vs historical) | 10% | | |
| Industry Attractiveness | 5% | | |
| **TOTAL** | **100%** | | **___/10** |
**Interpretation:**
- **8-10:** Strong Buy (conviction tinggi)
- **6-8:** Buy (masuk watchlist, wait for better price)
- **4-6:** Hold/Pass (ada concern)
- **< 4:** Avoid (too many red flags)
**Example: BBCA Scoring**
| Kategori | Weight | Score | Weighted |
|---------|--------|-------|---------|
| Business Model Clarity | 10% | 9 | 0.9 |
| Competitive Moat | 15% | 9 | 1.35 |
| Management | 10% | 8 | 0.8 |
| Financial Health | 15% | 9 | 1.35 |
| Profitability | 20% | 9 | 1.8 |
| Growth | 15% | 7 | 1.05 |
| Valuation | 10% | 6 | 0.6 |
| Industry | 5% | 8 | 0.4 |
| **TOTAL** | **100%** | | **8.25/10** |
**Conclusion:** Strong Buy (fundamentally excellent, valuasi slightly expensive tapi masih acceptable)
---
## 5. STAGE 4: Bandarmologi Check (Follow the Smart Money)
Setelah fundamental oke, cek: **Siapa yang beli/jual?**
### A. Foreign Flow Analysis (IDN Specific)
**Where to Check:**
- RTI Business (Daily Foreign Net)
- Stockbit (Foreign Activity)
- IDX Website (Foreign Transaction Summary)
**Metrics:**
| **Metric** | **Bullish Signal** | **Bearish Signal** |
|-----------|-------------------|-------------------|
| **Foreign Net Buy/Sell** | Net buy > Rp 50M/hari (sustained) | Net sell > Rp 100M/hari |
| **Foreign Ownership %** | Naik dari 20% → 30% (accumulation) | Turun dari 40% → 30% (distribution) |
| **Avg Foreign Buy Price** | Di atas current price (mereka average up) | Di bawah current price (cutting loss) |
**Example Analysis:**
```
BBCA (Check di RTI):
├─ Foreign Net Buy: +Rp 200M (3 hari terakhir)
├─ Foreign Ownership: 45% (historical 40-48%)
├─ Trend: Accumulation
└─ Conclusion: Institutional masih percaya, positive signal
```
---
### B. Broker Analysis (Siapa yang Agresif Beli/Jual?)
**Top Broker to Watch (IDN):**
| **Broker Code** | **Entity** | **Characteristic** |
|----------------|-----------|-------------------|
| **YP** | Mirae Asset | Foreign institutional |
| **GT** | Mandiri Sekuritas | Domestic institutional |
| **OP** | UOB Kay Hian | Foreign institutional |
| **MG** | Morgan Stanley | Foreign institutional |
| **PD** | Phillip Securities | Mixed |
| **Retail dominan** | Banyak kode kecil (AM, RK, dll) | Biasanya weak hands |
**How to Read (Stockbit/RTI - Broker Summary):**
```
BBCA Today:
Top 5 Buyer:
1. YP (Foreign) - Rp 50M
2. GT (Domestic Inst) - Rp 30M
3. OP (Foreign) - Rp 25M
...
Top 5 Seller:
1. AM (Retail) - Rp 15M
2. RK (Retail) - Rp 10M
...
Interpretation:
✅ Institutional buying, retail selling = STRONG BUY signal
❌ Retail buying, institutional selling = Distribution (AVOID)
```
---
### C. Volume & Price Action Analysis
**Pattern Bandarmologi:**
#### **1. Accumulation (Bandar sedang kumpulin)**
```
Characteristics:
├─ Price sideways/turun perlahan (3-6 bulan)
├─ Volume rendah saat turun
├─ Volume spike saat naik sedikit
├─ Foreign/big broker net buy konsisten (meski price turun)
└─ Support level kuat (buywall)
Example Chart Pattern:
Price: ~~~~__~~~~__~~~~ (ranging)
Volume: low low low SPIKE low low SPIKE
Action: ACCUMULATE bertahap (DCA)
```
#### **2. Distribution (Bandar sedang jual)**
```
Characteristics:
├─ Price sideways setelah rally panjang
├─ Volume tinggi tapi price ga naik-naik
├─ Foreign/big broker net sell
├─ Resistance level kuat (sellwall)
└─ Breakdown dari support = konfirmasi
Example:
Price: Naik 50% → sideways 2 bulan → breakdown
Volume: SPIKE tinggi saat sideways
Action: AVOID atau TAKE PROFIT
```
#### **3. Markup (Bandar sedang naikkan)**
```
Characteristics:
├─ Price breakout dari accumulation zone
├─ Volume meningkat saat naik
├─ Pullback volume rendah (weak selling)
├─ Higher high, higher low (uptrend jelas)
Action: BUY on pullback, HOLD jika sudah punya
```
#### **4. Markdown (Bandar sedang turunkan/keluar)**
```
Characteristics:
├─ Price breakdown dari distribution zone
├─ Volume tinggi saat turun
├─ Rally volume rendah (dead cat bounce)
├─ Lower low, lower high (downtrend)
Action: AVOID, atau wait for capitulation bottom
```
---
### D. Tools Bandarmologi (IDN)
**Free:**
- **Stockbit:** Broker summary, foreign flow
- **RTI Business:** Real-time broker data (premium feature)
- **IPOT (Indo Premier):** Broker analysis
**Advanced (Paid):**
- **Ajaib Sekuritas Pro:** Heat map transaksi broker
- **Phintraco Sekuritas:** Bandarmology tools
**Manual Method (Free):**
```
1. Buka idx.co.id
2. Market Data → Trading Summary → By Broker
3. Download Excel
4. Analisa manual:
├─ Sum total buy per broker
├─ Sum total sell per broker
└─ Net = Buy - Sell
```
---
## 6. STAGE 5: Technical Timing (When to Press the Buy Button)
Fundamental ✅, Bandarmologi ✅ → **Sekarang: Kapan entry?**
### A. Multi-Timeframe Analysis
**Rule:** Align 3 timeframes
| **Timeframe** | **Purpose** | **Indicator Focus** |
|--------------|-----------|-------------------|
| **Monthly** | Trend utama | MA 200, support/resistance major |
| **Weekly** | Trend menengah | MA 50/200, RSI, MACD |
| **Daily** | Timing entry | Candlestick pattern, volume, Fib retracement |
**Ideal Entry Setup:**
```
Monthly: Uptrend (price > MA200)
↓
Weekly: Pullback ke MA50 atau support
↓
Daily: Reversal pattern (hammer, bullish engulfing) + volume surge
↓
ENTRY
```
---
### B. Key Technical Levels
#### **1. Support & Resistance (Horizontal)**
**How to Identify:**
```
1. Buka chart 1 tahun (daily)
2. Tandai level dimana price "memantul" berkali-kali
3. Level yang tersentuh 3x+ = strong S/R
```
**Usage:**
```
Entry: Buy dekat support (risk kecil, SL jelas)
Avoid: Buy dekat resistance (risk besar, bisa reject)
Example BBCA:
Support: Rp 8,500 (tersentuh 4x dalam 6 bulan)
Resistance: Rp 9,500
Current: Rp 9,000
Action: Wait pullback ke 8,500-8,700 (risk-reward optimal)
```
---
#### **2. Moving Averages**
**Setup:**
- MA 20 (short-term)
- MA 50 (medium-term)
- MA 200 (long-term)
**Golden Cross (Bullish):**
```
MA 50 cross above MA 200 = Strong buy signal
Example: Terjadi setelah base building 6-12 bulan
```
**Death Cross (Bearish):**
```
MA 50 cross below MA 200 = Avoid/sell signal
```
**Pullback Strategy:**
```
Uptrend (price > MA200):
├─ Buy saat price pullback ke MA50
├─ SL below MA50
└─ Target: Previous high atau resistance
Example:
Price: Rp 10,000
MA50: Rp 9,500
MA200: Rp 9,000
Setup:
├─ Buy: 9,500-9,600 (bounce dari MA50)
├─ SL: 9,300 (below MA50)
├─ Target: 10,500 (previous resistance)
└─ Risk-Reward: (10,500-9,500)/(9,500-9,300) = 1,000/200 = 5:1 ✅
```
---
#### **3. RSI (Relative Strength Index)**
**Settings:** 14 period
**Zones:**
- **> 70:** Overbought (hati-hati, bisa koreksi)
- **30-70:** Neutral
- **< 30:** Oversold (buy opportunity)
**Strategy:**
```
Strong Uptrend + RSI < 40 (pada pullback) = BUY
Weak/Downtrend + RSI > 60 = AVOID (bear rally)
Divergence (Advanced):
Price: Higher high
RSI: Lower high
└─ Bearish divergence (momentum melemah) = warning signal
```
---
#### **4. Volume Confirmation**
**Rule:** Price naik dengan volume tinggi = healthy
Price naik dengan volume rendah = weak (likely reversal)
**Pattern:**
```
Breakout + Volume > 2x avg volume = Valid breakout
Breakout + Volume normal/rendah = False breakout (biasanya fail)
```
**Example:**
```
BBCA breakout resistance 9,500:
├─ Volume: 50 juta lembar (avg: 20 juta)
└─ Conclusion: Valid breakout, momentum kuat
vs
GOTO breakout resistance 100:
├─ Volume: 200 juta lembar (avg: 300 juta)
└─ Conclusion: Weak breakout, likely bull trap
```
---
### C. Entry Patterns (High Probability)
#### **1. Pullback Entry (Safest)**
```
Conditions:
├─ Trend: Uptrend (price > MA200)
├─ Pullback: Price turun ke MA50 atau Fib 0.382-0.5
├─ RSI: 40-50 (not oversold tapi mulai rebound)
├─ Candlestick: Hammer/bullish engulfing
└─ Volume: Surge on reversal day
Entry: Close di atas reversal candle
SL: Below low of reversal candle
Target: Previous high atau Fib extension 1.618
```
**Chart Example:**
```
Price: Uptrend dari 8,000 → 10,000
Pullback: 10,000 → 9,200 (touch MA50)
Reversal: Hammer candle @ 9,200, volume 2x avg
Entry: 9,300 (close above hammer)
SL: 9,000 (below hammer low)
Target: 10,500
RR: (10,500-9,300)/(9,300-9,000) = 4:1 ✅
```
---
#### **2. Breakout Entry (Aggressive)**
```
Conditions:
├─ Base building: Minimal 3 bulan consolidation
├─ Resistance: Tersentuh 3x+ (strong resistance)
├─ Volume: Dry up during consolidation
├─ Breakout: Price close > resistance dengan volume surge (>2x avg)
└─ Retest: Price pullback ke resistance (now become support), lalu bounce
Entry: Pada retest support (ex-resistance)
SL: Below retest low
Target: Measured move (tinggi base = target dari breakout)
```
**Chart Example:**
```
Base: 8,000-9,000 (6 bulan)
Resistance: 9,000
Breakout: Close 9,100 dengan volume 3x avg
Retest: Turun ke 9,000, bounce
Entry: 9,050
SL: 8,850
Target: 9,000 + (9,000-8,000) = 10,000 (measured move)
```
---
#### **3. Reversal Bottom (Contrarian, High Risk High Reward)**
```
Conditions:
├─ Downtrend berkepanjangan (3-6 bulan)
├─ Capitulation: Volume spike ekstrem + price crash
├─ Hammer/bullish engulfing di support major
├─ RSI: < 30 (deep oversold)
├─ Divergence: Price lower low, RSI higher low (bullish divergence)
Entry: Close di atas reversal candle
SL: Tight (5-7% below entry)
Target: MA50 atau Fib 0.5 retracement
⚠️ High risk: Bisa jadi falling knife (catch lebih cepat dari seharusnya)
```
---
### D. Position Sizing & Risk Management per Trade
**Formula:**
```
Position Size = (Total Portfolio × Risk% per trade) / (Entry price - SL price)
Example:
├─ Portfolio: Rp 100 juta
├─ Risk per trade: 1% = Rp 1 juta
├─ Entry: Rp 9,500
├─ SL: Rp 9,000
├─ Risk per share: 500
Position Size = 1,000,000 / 500 = 2,000 shares
Investment = 2,000 × 9,500 = Rp 19 juta (19% dari portfolio)
Jika SL kena: Loss = Rp 1 juta (1% portfolio) ✅
Jika target Rp 11,000 tercapai: Gain = 2,000 × 1,500 = Rp 3 juta (3% portfolio)
Risk-Reward: 3:1 ✅
```
**Rules:**
- Max risk per trade: **1-2%** dari total portfolio
- Max allocation per stock: **15-20%** dari portfolio (untuk blue chip), **5-10%** (untuk speculative)
- Jika conviction sangat tinggi: Max 25% (rare case)
---
## 7. Putting It All Together: Full Example (BBCA Case Study)
### **STAGE 1: Universe Definition**
```
Top Down (Sesi 3):
├─ Cycle: Early easing (Fed mulai dovish)
├─ Sektor pilihan: Financials
├─ Market: 40% IDN
└─ Focus: Banking sector
Filter Liquidity:
└─ Market cap > 10T, avg value > 50M
Result: 10 bank stocks (BBCA, BBRI, BMRI, BBNI, dll)
```
---
### **STAGE 2: Quantitative Screening**
**Metrics Comparison (4 Big Banks):**
| **Ticker** | **ROE** | **PER** | **PBV** | **DER** | **CAR** | **NPL** | **NIM** |
|-----------|--------|--------|--------|--------|--------|--------|--------|
| **BBCA** | 18% | 18x | 4.5x | 6.2x | 25% | 0.4% | 6.5% |
| **BBRI** | 16% | 12x | 2.8x | 6.5x | 23% | 2.1% | 7.2% |
| **BMRI** | 14% | 11x | 2.2x | 7.0x | 22% | 2.3% | 5.8% |
| **BBNI** | 13% | 10x | 1.8x | 7.2x | 20% | 2.5% | 5.5% |
**Interpretation:**
```
BBCA: Premium valuation (PER 18x, PBV 4.5x), justified by:
├─ Highest ROE (18%)
├─ Lowest NPL (0.4% - best asset quality)
├─ Highest CAR (25% - very strong capital)
└─ Proven track record
BBRI: More attractive valuation (PER 12x), high NIM (7.2%)
└─ Good alternative (value play)
Conclusion: BBCA = quality, BBRI = value
```
---
### **STAGE 3: Quality Check**
**BBCA Deep Dive:**
```
Business Model:
✅ Diversified (retail, SME, corporate)
✅ Fee-based income strong (40% of revenue)
✅ Digital transformation leader (BCA Mobile, Blu)
Moat:
✅ Brand (top-of-mind untuk banking)
✅ Network (largest ATM, 1,200+ branches)
✅ Switching cost (customer loyalty tinggi)
✅ Digital ecosystem
Management:
✅ Consistent leadership (CEO tenure panjang)
✅ Track record: ROE > 15% sustained 10+ years
✅ Insider ownership: Djarum Group 50%+ (aligned interest)
Financial Deep Dive:
✅ Revenue CAGR 3Y: 8%
✅ EPS CAGR 3Y: 10%
✅ FCF positive & growing
✅ Dividend payout 40-50% (sustainable)
Industry:
✅ Indonesian banking masih underpenetrated (growth potential)
✅ Digital banking competition rising (risk), tapi BBCA adapting well
Scoring: 8.5/10 (Strong Buy fundamentally)
```
---
### **STAGE 4: Bandarmologi**
**Check RTI Business (Example data):**
```
Foreign Flow (7 hari terakhir):
├─ Day 1: +Rp 50M
├─ Day 2: +Rp 120M
├─ Day 3: -Rp 30M
├─ Day 4: +Rp 80M
├─ Day 5: +Rp 100M
├─ Day 6: +Rp 60M
└─ Day 7: +Rp 40M
Total: +Rp 420M (Net Buy)
Foreign Ownership: 48% (near historical high 50%)
Top Buyer Brokers:
1. YP (Mirae Asset) - Foreign
2. GT (Mandiri Sekuritas) - Domestic Inst
3. OP (UOB) - Foreign
Conclusion: Institutional accumulation, positive signal ✅
```
**Volume Analysis:**
```
Avg Volume: 25 juta shares/hari
Last 3 days: 30-35 juta shares (above average)
Price action: Sideways dengan volume meningkat (possible accumulation)
```
---
### **STAGE 5: Technical Timing**
**Chart Analysis (Assume current price: Rp 9,200):**
```
Monthly Chart:
├─ Trend: Uptrend (above MA200 @ 8,500)
├─ Pattern: Higher lows formation
└─ Bias: Bullish ✅
Weekly Chart:
├─ MA50: Rp 9,000
├─ MA200: Rp 8,500
├─ Current: Pullback dari 9,800 → 9,200 (touch MA50)
├─ RSI: 48 (neutral, not oversold)
└─ MACD: Bullish crossover forming
Daily Chart:
├─ Pattern: Hammer candle @ 9,150 (yesterday)
├─ Volume: 40 juta shares (1.6x avg)
├─ Support: 9,000 (MA50 weekly, also horizontal support)
├─ Resistance: 9,800 (previous high)
Entry Setup:
├─ Entry: 9,250 (close above hammer)
├─ SL: 8,950 (below MA50 & hammer low)
├─ Target 1: 9,800 (previous high)
├─ Target 2: 10,200 (Fib extension 1.618)
Risk-Reward:
├─ Risk: 9,250 - 8,950 = 300
├─ Reward (T1): 9,800 - 9,250 = 550
├─ RR Ratio: 550/300 = 1.83:1 (acceptable, ideally >2:1)
Position Sizing (Portfolio Rp 100 juta, risk 1%):
├─ Risk: Rp 1 juta
├─ Risk per share: Rp 300
├─ Position: 1,000,000 / 300 = 3,333 shares
├─ Investment: 3,333 × 9,250 = Rp 30.8 juta (30.8% portfolio)
Adjustment: Agak besar untuk 1 stock, turunkan jadi 2,500 shares (23% portfolio)
```
---
### **FINAL DECISION:**
```
✅ Fundamental: Excellent (8.5/10)
✅ Bandarmologi: Positive (institutional buying)
✅ Technical: Good setup (pullback to support, reversal forming)
ACTION: BUY 2,500 shares @ 9,250
SL: 8,950
Target: 9,800-10,200
Risk: 1% portfolio
Time horizon: 3-6 bulan (swing trade) atau hold long-term (investment)
```
---
## 8. Template Watchlist & Tracking
### A. Watchlist Structure (Google Sheets/Excel)
**Columns:**
| Ticker | Sector | Stage | Fundamental Score | Bandarmologi | Technical | Entry Target | Current Price | Status |
|--------|--------|-------|------------------|--------------|-----------|--------------|---------------|--------|
| BBCA | Financials | 5 (Ready) | 8.5/10 | Accumulation | Pullback | 9,000-9,300 | 9,200 | BUY ✅ |
| BBRI | Financials | 4 (Need tech confirm) | 7.8/10 | Neutral | Ranging | 4,500-4,600 | 4,700 | WAIT |
| ICBP | Cons Staples | 3 (Need bandarmologi check) | 8/10 | - | Uptrend | 10,000-10,200 | 10,500 | WAIT |
---
### B. Trade Journal Template
**Per Trade (Mandatory!):**
```
Entry Date: __________
Ticker: __________
Entry Price: __________
Position Size: __________ shares (___% portfolio)
Entry Reason:
├─ Fundamental: ___________________
├─ Bandarmologi: __________________
└─ Technical: _____________________
Stop Loss: __________
Target: __________
Risk-Reward: __________
Exit Date: __________
Exit Price: __________
Result: +/- _____% (+/- Rp _______)
Lessons Learned:
___________________________________
```
**Review Monthly:**
- Win rate: ____%
- Avg gain: ____%
- Avg loss: ____%
- Expectancy: (Win rate × Avg gain) - (Loss rate × Avg loss)
---
## 9. Common Mistakes & How to Avoid
### ❌ **Mistake 1: Skip Top Down, Langsung Stock Picking**
```
Problem: Beli saham bagus di sektor yang salah cycle
Fix: ALWAYS start dari Layer 1-3 (Sesi 3), baru stock picking
```
### ❌ **Mistake 2: Falling in Love with a Stock**
```
Problem: Hold terus meski fundamental berubah (sunk cost fallacy)
Fix: Set objective criteria untuk sell (fundamental deteriorate, SL kena, target tercapai)
```
### ❌ **Mistake 3: Over-Diversification**
```
Problem: Punya 30 stocks, tidak tracking semua
Fix: Max 10-15 stocks untuk active portfolio (retail investor)
```
### ❌ **Mistake 4: Ignore Position Sizing**
```
Problem: All-in 1 stock, jika salah = portfolio hancur
Fix: Max 15-20% per stock (blue chip), 5-10% (speculative)
```
### ❌ **Mistake 5: No Stop Loss**
```
Problem: Floating loss -30%, -40%, hoping for recovery
Fix: ALWAYS set SL, max loss per trade 1-2% portfolio
```
---
## 10. Action Plan Post-Sesi 4
### **Week 1:**
- [ ] Setup screener (Stockbit/Finviz)
- [ ] Jalankan filter quantitative untuk 3 sektor dari top down
- [ ] Export hasil ke spreadsheet
### **Week 2:**
- [ ] Deep dive fundamental 10 stocks dari hasil screener
- [ ] Scoring masing-masing (template scoring di atas)
- [ ] Shortlist 5 stocks dengan score > 7/10
### **Week 3:**
- [ ] Bandarmologi check untuk 5 stocks
- [ ] Technical analysis, tentukan entry level
### **Week 4:**
- [ ] Execute: Buy 2-3 stocks dengan best setup
- [ ] Set SL & alert
- [ ] Start trade journal
---
## Kesimpulan Sesi 4
**Key Takeaways:**
1. **Screening adalah funnel sistematis** - dari 800 stocks jadi 3-5 conviction buys
2. **Quantitative + Qualitative** - numbers don't lie, tapi context matters
3. **Bandarmologi confirms fundamental** - ikuti smart money
4. **Technical untuk timing** - buy right stock at right price
5. **Position sizing protects capital** - no single trade should kill portfolio
**Hierarchy:**
```
Top Down (Macro/Sector) > Fundamental > Bandarmologi > Technical > Position Sizing
```
---
## Preview Sesi 5: Screening Obligasi, Emas & Forex
Setelah deep dive saham, next session:
- **Obligasi:** Cara screening SBN vs corporate bonds, yield hunting strategy
- **Emas:** Kapan buy/sell emas berdasarkan makro (real yield, USD, inflation)
- **Forex:** Pair selection, carry trade strategy, risk management forex
**Plus:**
- Portfolio integration: Kapan rotate dari saham ke obligasi?
- Crisis hedging: Berapa % emas ideal dalam berbagai skenario?
---
**Lanjut Sesi 5, atau ada bagian Sesi 4 yang perlu diperdalam?**
